Tuesday, December 28, 2004
today's papers50,000?By Eric UmanskyPosted Tuesday, Dec. 28, 2004, at 12:26 AM PT
Everybody leads with the tsunamis, which U.N. officials now estimate have killed at least 25,000, about half in Sri Lanka. But as the Los Angeles Times emphasizes, the total could double—not accounting the epidemics that officials fear are brewing.
"This may be the worst natural disaster in recent history," said a U.N. spokesman. Asked about the situation in the Indonesian province of Aceh, which was right next to the earthquake, he said, "We have no idea."
Indonesia's vice president visited the province and estimated that "between 21,000 and 25,000 people" died there. If that's accurate, it would make for about 45,000 killed overall. The New York Times, citing the American consulate, says water in Aceh reached up to 10 miles inland. The Washington Post has more detail, noting that water is still moving through parts of the capital, where the vice president estimated 5,000 dead. Aceh has an ongoing rebellion and for roughly the past year has been closed to foreign relief workers and reporters. (Indonesian officials told the WP they're reversing that policy.)
In just one incident in Sri Lanka, about 1,500 were killed when a train was overwhelmed by water. The NYT mentions that about a million Sri Lankans were made homeless. And the Wall Street Journal flags a particular problem. "Sri Lanka is one of the most heavily land-mined countries in the world," said a U.N. official, who explained that the waters probably moved many mines and washed away markers. The Journal mentions that the U.N. is preparing to distribute aid to all of 2,000 Sri Lankan families.
Two Indian islands, Andaman and Nicobar, were also near the original quake and have yet to fully report in. Local officials estimate at least 5,000 dead.
Late yesterday, Somalia, which is about 3,000 miles away from the quake, announced what the WSJ calls "hundreds of deaths."
USA Today says up high in display type that "hundreds of Americans" are unaccounted for. The paper cites Secretary of State Powell. What it doesn't mention is that Powell followed that by saying, "It just means we haven't been able to reach out and get contact with them. It does not imply that they are necessarily injured or in any way a casualty." The State Dept. has set up a toll-free number for worried family members: 888-407-4747.
The Journal mentions that most "industrial infrastructure such as ports, as well as critical tourist facilities, are in better shape than many initially feared."
The papers all list places to donate.
The WP, alone, fronts the latest from Iraq: A suicide car bomb targeted the HQ of the country's top Shiite party; killing 15 and wounding about 70. And as the Post emphasizes, the Sunni party with the largest number of candidates fielded said it's withdrawing from the elections, citing security concerns. One Iraqi analyst said the party pulled out because it figured it wouldn't win many seats since Sunni turnout is looking to be way low.
The Post says voter registration in Sunni areas has "lagged far behind" other regions. Polls have suggested that most Sunnis want to vote, but there's the question of security and intimidation. The WP says there's a leaflet going around headlined, "Ultimatum Warning Threat." It said anybody who votes will be "liquidated within 48 hours."
The Christian Science Monitor also has a detailed piece on the depressing registration numbers.
Knight Ridder says that despite insisting otherwise, some top Shiite politicians seem to support the idea of a theocracy.
With just about all votes counted, Ukraine's opposition candidate, Viktor Yushenko, has been declared the winner in what observers said was an election clear of fraud. His opponent, Prime Minister Viktor Yanukovich claimed ... fraud and said he'll challenge the results in court. The NYT says it will be a "lonely fight." Few supporters showed up in the capital for a planned rally and the parliament just ignored him, announcing plans for an inauguration.USAT stuffs an interview with the recently retired inspector general for the Department of Homeland Security. Clark Kent Ervin (his parents dug Superman) had written report after report detailing DHS shortcomings. And he continues that tradition, telling USAT that the department wastes millions through an accounting division that is "chaotic and disorganized." Asked what else is wrong with the agency he said, "It's difficult to figure out where to start." Ervin's reports were widely praised by outsiders and he could have been reappointed. One named Republican Senate staffer called the move not to do so "purely a White House decision."Eric Umansky writes "Today's Papers" for Slate. He can be reached at todayspapers@hotmail.com.Article URL: http://slate.msn.com/id/2111458/
Everybody leads with the tsunamis, which U.N. officials now estimate have killed at least 25,000, about half in Sri Lanka. But as the Los Angeles Times emphasizes, the total could double—not accounting the epidemics that officials fear are brewing.
"This may be the worst natural disaster in recent history," said a U.N. spokesman. Asked about the situation in the Indonesian province of Aceh, which was right next to the earthquake, he said, "We have no idea."
Indonesia's vice president visited the province and estimated that "between 21,000 and 25,000 people" died there. If that's accurate, it would make for about 45,000 killed overall. The New York Times, citing the American consulate, says water in Aceh reached up to 10 miles inland. The Washington Post has more detail, noting that water is still moving through parts of the capital, where the vice president estimated 5,000 dead. Aceh has an ongoing rebellion and for roughly the past year has been closed to foreign relief workers and reporters. (Indonesian officials told the WP they're reversing that policy.)
In just one incident in Sri Lanka, about 1,500 were killed when a train was overwhelmed by water. The NYT mentions that about a million Sri Lankans were made homeless. And the Wall Street Journal flags a particular problem. "Sri Lanka is one of the most heavily land-mined countries in the world," said a U.N. official, who explained that the waters probably moved many mines and washed away markers. The Journal mentions that the U.N. is preparing to distribute aid to all of 2,000 Sri Lankan families.
Two Indian islands, Andaman and Nicobar, were also near the original quake and have yet to fully report in. Local officials estimate at least 5,000 dead.
Late yesterday, Somalia, which is about 3,000 miles away from the quake, announced what the WSJ calls "hundreds of deaths."
USA Today says up high in display type that "hundreds of Americans" are unaccounted for. The paper cites Secretary of State Powell. What it doesn't mention is that Powell followed that by saying, "It just means we haven't been able to reach out and get contact with them. It does not imply that they are necessarily injured or in any way a casualty." The State Dept. has set up a toll-free number for worried family members: 888-407-4747.
The Journal mentions that most "industrial infrastructure such as ports, as well as critical tourist facilities, are in better shape than many initially feared."
The papers all list places to donate.
The WP, alone, fronts the latest from Iraq: A suicide car bomb targeted the HQ of the country's top Shiite party; killing 15 and wounding about 70. And as the Post emphasizes, the Sunni party with the largest number of candidates fielded said it's withdrawing from the elections, citing security concerns. One Iraqi analyst said the party pulled out because it figured it wouldn't win many seats since Sunni turnout is looking to be way low.
The Post says voter registration in Sunni areas has "lagged far behind" other regions. Polls have suggested that most Sunnis want to vote, but there's the question of security and intimidation. The WP says there's a leaflet going around headlined, "Ultimatum Warning Threat." It said anybody who votes will be "liquidated within 48 hours."
The Christian Science Monitor also has a detailed piece on the depressing registration numbers.
Knight Ridder says that despite insisting otherwise, some top Shiite politicians seem to support the idea of a theocracy.
With just about all votes counted, Ukraine's opposition candidate, Viktor Yushenko, has been declared the winner in what observers said was an election clear of fraud. His opponent, Prime Minister Viktor Yanukovich claimed ... fraud and said he'll challenge the results in court. The NYT says it will be a "lonely fight." Few supporters showed up in the capital for a planned rally and the parliament just ignored him, announcing plans for an inauguration.USAT stuffs an interview with the recently retired inspector general for the Department of Homeland Security. Clark Kent Ervin (his parents dug Superman) had written report after report detailing DHS shortcomings. And he continues that tradition, telling USAT that the department wastes millions through an accounting division that is "chaotic and disorganized." Asked what else is wrong with the agency he said, "It's difficult to figure out where to start." Ervin's reports were widely praised by outsiders and he could have been reappointed. One named Republican Senate staffer called the move not to do so "purely a White House decision."Eric Umansky writes "Today's Papers" for Slate. He can be reached at todayspapers@hotmail.com.Article URL: http://slate.msn.com/id/2111458/
December 28, 2004
ASIA'S DEADLY WAVES: THE OVERVIEW; TOLL IN UNDERSEA EARTHQUAKE PASSES 25,000; A THIRD OF THE DEAD ARE SAID TO BE CHILDREN By SETH MYDANS; Warren Hoge contributed reporting from the United Nations for this article, and Wayne Arnold from Lhokseumawe, Indonesia. Survivors of the gigantic undersea earthquake on Sunday that swallowed coastlines from Indonesia to Africa -- which officials now describe as one of the worst natural disasters in recent history -- recovered bodies on Tuesday, hurriedly arranged for mass burials and searched for tens of thousands of the missing in countries thousands of miles apart.
The toll from the disaster -- with more than 25,000 dead and many unaccounted for -- came into sharper relief on a day when it seemed increasingly clear that at least a third of the dead were children, according to estimates by aid officials.
The International Red Cross and government officials here, as well as those in Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, India, the Maldives and as far away as Somalia, warned that with hundreds of thousands of people stranded in the open without clean drinking water, epidemics of cholera and other waterborne diseases could take as many lives as the initial waves.
Images from around the region presented a tableau of unrelenting grief. Fathers and mothers wailed over drowned children. Bodies were arrayed in long rows in hastily dug trenches. Villagers sat by ruined homes, stunned. Hotels in some of Thailand's most luxurious resorts were turned into morgues.
''This may be the worst natural disaster in recent history because it is affecting so many heavily populated coastal areas,'' said Jan Egeland, the emergency relief coordinator for the United Nations, speaking at a news conference in New York.
''Usually a natural disaster strikes one or two or three countries, not eight or nine enormous coastlines like they've done here,'' he added. ''Bigger waves have been recorded. But no wave has affected so many people.'' Nearly half the reported deaths were here in Sri Lanka, where estimates jumped Monday to more than 12,000 killed, and where more than a million people were reported to have lost their homes.
The realization began to emerge Tuesday that the dead included an exceptionally high number of children who, aid officials suggested, were least able to grab onto trees or boats when the deadly waves smashed through villages and over beaches. Children make up at least half the population of Asia.
On the western tip of the Indonesian island of Sumatra, the destruction was doubly fierce, caused by both the earthquake itself 150 miles away and the tsunamis that followed. The Associated Press reported from the provincial capital, Banda Aceh, that bloated bodies filled the streets and thousands of survivors huddled without shelter. The American Consulate in nearby Medan has received reports that waters around Banda Aceh reached as far as 10 miles inland. The floodwaters reportedly inundated one city hospital, drowning patients inside.
Some 5,000 people are confirmed dead but that number is expected at least to double. Indonesia's vice president, Jusuf Kalla, said he attended a mass burial of 1,500. The area has been closed to journalists and aid workers because of a civil war, and only a few local journalists have gotten in.
Mr. Egeland said, ''We haven't a clue'' as to the number affected in Aceh. He said it had been impossible to reach contacts there, which he called ''a bad sign.''
India reported more than 4,000 dead on the mainland. Hundreds were dead or missing in the southern resort islands of Thailand, many of them foreign vacationers.
Mr. Egeland said the big problem now was to coordinate the huge international aid effort, a particularly daunting challenge given how widespread the devastation is. He said the total damage would ''probably be many billions of dollars.''
''We cannot fathom the cost of these poor societies and the nameless fishermen and fishing villages and so on that have just been wiped out,'' he said. ''Hundreds of thousands of livelihoods have gone.''
Amateur videotape played on television showed terrifying scenes from several countries of huge walls of water crashing through palm trees and over the tops of buildings and roaring up coastal streets with cars and debris bobbing on the surface.
To backdrops of screams and shouts, people were shown clinging to buildings, being swept away by the current, running for their lives, weeping, carrying the injured and cradling dead children.
As the water receded, almost as quickly as it had arrived, bodies were seen in the branches of trees, and broken cars and houses littered the shores as if a tornado had struck. Some of the bodies and debris were sucked back out to sea.
There were fears of thousands more deaths on India's Andaman and Nicobar Islands, where most communications have been cut off.
''In Andamans and Nicobar Islands, the death toll is over 3,000,'' said Rana Mathew, a government spokesman. ''The southern islands are the most affected. No contact with the island of Nancoveri been established as yet. So the death toll might go up. And thousands of people are missing.''
Smaller numbers of deaths were reported in Malaysia, the Maldives, Myanmar, Bangladesh and the Seychelles, as well as along the distant African coastline, particularly Somalia, where entire villages were reported to have disappeared.
''All of the fishermen who went to sea haven't come back,'' said Yusuf Ismail, a spokesman for the president.
In Thailand, the government said 918 people had died, 7,396 were injured and thousands were missing, mostly on small resort islands or among boatloads of recreational divers who had headed out to sea in the morning before the wave struck.
''I would say the death toll would definitely exceed 1,000,'' Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra said after visiting Phuket Island, the most prominent of Thailand's beach resorts, where the death toll stood at 130. ''We have a long way to go in collecting bodies.''
Many of those killed there were foreigners, but the most prominent of the dead was Poom Jensen, 21, the Thai-American grandson of King Bhumipol Adulyadej.
The smaller island of Phi Phi Lei, which was the scene of the movie ''The Beach,'' starring Leonardo DiCaprio, was reported to have been mostly leveled. On another small island, the proprietors of the elite Phra Thong Resort said only 70 of 170 guests were accounted for.
Apart from the huge death toll, it was the presence of large number of foreign tourists that distinguished this disaster from the many floods and typhoons that take a heavy toll in the region every year.
In Sri Lanka, the government said as many as 200 foreign tourists had been killed. In Thailand, an official estimated that 20 to 30 percent of those killed had been foreigners. The victims were reported to include people from Germany, Japan, Italy, Sweden, France, Britain, the United States, Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Holland, Norway, Switzerland, Turkey, Spain and Russia. The number of Americans dead stood at eight, including a well-known fashion photographer, Fernando Bengoechea.
Those numbers were tiny, though, compared with the devastation suffered by the mostly poor fishermen, farmers and laborers who populate the low-lying coasts of these South Asian and Southeast Asian nations.
In Sri Lanka, Susil Premajayantha, a senior minister, said the homes of about 1.5 million people had been destroyed or damaged. Few have the resources to resume their lives without help.
He said 890 miles of railway track running south from the capital, Colombo, had been washed away. Local officials told The Associated Press that some 1,500 passengers had been trapped in railroad cars as an entire train was caught in the rushing tide and swept away.
At least 400 prisoners were reported to have escaped during the chaos from two jails in the southern area, and officials offered them an amnesty to turn themselves in. Across the region, police officers and soldiers patrolled in an effort to halt looting.
The United States Geological Survey said the 9.0 magnitude earthquake on Sunday morning was the fourth-largest in a century and the largest in the world since 1964, when an earthquake measuring 9.2 hit Alaska. A number of strong aftershocks have followed.
''We have ordered 15,000 troops into the field to search for survivors,'' said Edy Sulistiadi, a spokesman for the Indonesian military, which is fighting separatist rebels in the area. ''They are mostly retrieving corpses.''
Correction: December 29, 2004, Wednesday Because of an editing error, an article yesterday about the rising death toll from sea waves after the earthquake in Asia on Sunday misstated the known fate of an American photographer, Fernando Bengoechea, and his specialty. Known for interior design photography rather than fashion, he has been listed as missing, not dead.
Copyright 2005 The New York Times Company Permissions Privacy Policy
ASIA'S DEADLY WAVES: THE OVERVIEW; TOLL IN UNDERSEA EARTHQUAKE PASSES 25,000; A THIRD OF THE DEAD ARE SAID TO BE CHILDREN By SETH MYDANS; Warren Hoge contributed reporting from the United Nations for this article, and Wayne Arnold from Lhokseumawe, Indonesia. Survivors of the gigantic undersea earthquake on Sunday that swallowed coastlines from Indonesia to Africa -- which officials now describe as one of the worst natural disasters in recent history -- recovered bodies on Tuesday, hurriedly arranged for mass burials and searched for tens of thousands of the missing in countries thousands of miles apart.
The toll from the disaster -- with more than 25,000 dead and many unaccounted for -- came into sharper relief on a day when it seemed increasingly clear that at least a third of the dead were children, according to estimates by aid officials.
The International Red Cross and government officials here, as well as those in Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, India, the Maldives and as far away as Somalia, warned that with hundreds of thousands of people stranded in the open without clean drinking water, epidemics of cholera and other waterborne diseases could take as many lives as the initial waves.
Images from around the region presented a tableau of unrelenting grief. Fathers and mothers wailed over drowned children. Bodies were arrayed in long rows in hastily dug trenches. Villagers sat by ruined homes, stunned. Hotels in some of Thailand's most luxurious resorts were turned into morgues.
''This may be the worst natural disaster in recent history because it is affecting so many heavily populated coastal areas,'' said Jan Egeland, the emergency relief coordinator for the United Nations, speaking at a news conference in New York.
''Usually a natural disaster strikes one or two or three countries, not eight or nine enormous coastlines like they've done here,'' he added. ''Bigger waves have been recorded. But no wave has affected so many people.'' Nearly half the reported deaths were here in Sri Lanka, where estimates jumped Monday to more than 12,000 killed, and where more than a million people were reported to have lost their homes.
The realization began to emerge Tuesday that the dead included an exceptionally high number of children who, aid officials suggested, were least able to grab onto trees or boats when the deadly waves smashed through villages and over beaches. Children make up at least half the population of Asia.
On the western tip of the Indonesian island of Sumatra, the destruction was doubly fierce, caused by both the earthquake itself 150 miles away and the tsunamis that followed. The Associated Press reported from the provincial capital, Banda Aceh, that bloated bodies filled the streets and thousands of survivors huddled without shelter. The American Consulate in nearby Medan has received reports that waters around Banda Aceh reached as far as 10 miles inland. The floodwaters reportedly inundated one city hospital, drowning patients inside.
Some 5,000 people are confirmed dead but that number is expected at least to double. Indonesia's vice president, Jusuf Kalla, said he attended a mass burial of 1,500. The area has been closed to journalists and aid workers because of a civil war, and only a few local journalists have gotten in.
Mr. Egeland said, ''We haven't a clue'' as to the number affected in Aceh. He said it had been impossible to reach contacts there, which he called ''a bad sign.''
India reported more than 4,000 dead on the mainland. Hundreds were dead or missing in the southern resort islands of Thailand, many of them foreign vacationers.
Mr. Egeland said the big problem now was to coordinate the huge international aid effort, a particularly daunting challenge given how widespread the devastation is. He said the total damage would ''probably be many billions of dollars.''
''We cannot fathom the cost of these poor societies and the nameless fishermen and fishing villages and so on that have just been wiped out,'' he said. ''Hundreds of thousands of livelihoods have gone.''
Amateur videotape played on television showed terrifying scenes from several countries of huge walls of water crashing through palm trees and over the tops of buildings and roaring up coastal streets with cars and debris bobbing on the surface.
To backdrops of screams and shouts, people were shown clinging to buildings, being swept away by the current, running for their lives, weeping, carrying the injured and cradling dead children.
As the water receded, almost as quickly as it had arrived, bodies were seen in the branches of trees, and broken cars and houses littered the shores as if a tornado had struck. Some of the bodies and debris were sucked back out to sea.
There were fears of thousands more deaths on India's Andaman and Nicobar Islands, where most communications have been cut off.
''In Andamans and Nicobar Islands, the death toll is over 3,000,'' said Rana Mathew, a government spokesman. ''The southern islands are the most affected. No contact with the island of Nancoveri been established as yet. So the death toll might go up. And thousands of people are missing.''
Smaller numbers of deaths were reported in Malaysia, the Maldives, Myanmar, Bangladesh and the Seychelles, as well as along the distant African coastline, particularly Somalia, where entire villages were reported to have disappeared.
''All of the fishermen who went to sea haven't come back,'' said Yusuf Ismail, a spokesman for the president.
In Thailand, the government said 918 people had died, 7,396 were injured and thousands were missing, mostly on small resort islands or among boatloads of recreational divers who had headed out to sea in the morning before the wave struck.
''I would say the death toll would definitely exceed 1,000,'' Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra said after visiting Phuket Island, the most prominent of Thailand's beach resorts, where the death toll stood at 130. ''We have a long way to go in collecting bodies.''
Many of those killed there were foreigners, but the most prominent of the dead was Poom Jensen, 21, the Thai-American grandson of King Bhumipol Adulyadej.
The smaller island of Phi Phi Lei, which was the scene of the movie ''The Beach,'' starring Leonardo DiCaprio, was reported to have been mostly leveled. On another small island, the proprietors of the elite Phra Thong Resort said only 70 of 170 guests were accounted for.
Apart from the huge death toll, it was the presence of large number of foreign tourists that distinguished this disaster from the many floods and typhoons that take a heavy toll in the region every year.
In Sri Lanka, the government said as many as 200 foreign tourists had been killed. In Thailand, an official estimated that 20 to 30 percent of those killed had been foreigners. The victims were reported to include people from Germany, Japan, Italy, Sweden, France, Britain, the United States, Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Finland, Hungary, Holland, Norway, Switzerland, Turkey, Spain and Russia. The number of Americans dead stood at eight, including a well-known fashion photographer, Fernando Bengoechea.
Those numbers were tiny, though, compared with the devastation suffered by the mostly poor fishermen, farmers and laborers who populate the low-lying coasts of these South Asian and Southeast Asian nations.
In Sri Lanka, Susil Premajayantha, a senior minister, said the homes of about 1.5 million people had been destroyed or damaged. Few have the resources to resume their lives without help.
He said 890 miles of railway track running south from the capital, Colombo, had been washed away. Local officials told The Associated Press that some 1,500 passengers had been trapped in railroad cars as an entire train was caught in the rushing tide and swept away.
At least 400 prisoners were reported to have escaped during the chaos from two jails in the southern area, and officials offered them an amnesty to turn themselves in. Across the region, police officers and soldiers patrolled in an effort to halt looting.
The United States Geological Survey said the 9.0 magnitude earthquake on Sunday morning was the fourth-largest in a century and the largest in the world since 1964, when an earthquake measuring 9.2 hit Alaska. A number of strong aftershocks have followed.
''We have ordered 15,000 troops into the field to search for survivors,'' said Edy Sulistiadi, a spokesman for the Indonesian military, which is fighting separatist rebels in the area. ''They are mostly retrieving corpses.''
Correction: December 29, 2004, Wednesday Because of an editing error, an article yesterday about the rising death toll from sea waves after the earthquake in Asia on Sunday misstated the known fate of an American photographer, Fernando Bengoechea, and his specialty. Known for interior design photography rather than fashion, he has been listed as missing, not dead.
Copyright 2005 The New York Times Company Permissions Privacy Policy
